An Audio Break Out Box

 

Have you ever started a ham radio project and ended up learning something totally different along the way?  Well, that happened to me with my project to build an audio break out box (or audio splitter as it is sometimes called).  Besides ending up with a useful piece of equipment, I also mastered one versatile method of making printed circuit boards.  This project grew out of a desire to be able to share QSO experiences with others at Field Day.  During Field Day, contesting, general emergency communications, or almost any other ham radio activity, headphones are often a necessity because of the close proximity of operators to each other.  With stations located only a few feet apart, shouting into a microphone, or listening to CW on a loudspeaker might disrupt a nearby operator.  With a standard "y" connector two operators monitoring the same radio will often have trouble adjusting the individual volume to their headphones.

With this device, each operator hears only what he wants to hear and has the capability of adjusting the volume of his headset to his own preference.  Up to four people can monitor the same radio, but extra channels can be added by the builder.  The only other pieces of equipment needed are the headphones.  It makes it easy to share the Field Day experience, or for that matter, any other type of exciting ham operating experience with non hams who are also potential hams.  I call it BOB , which is short for Break Out Box.

The closest thing that I have found to what I wanted is shown in many recent editions of the ARRL handbook (see "Audio Breakout Box" by G4YNM, 2006 Handbook, Chapter 19.26).  In fact, I have pondered this article for years thinking of how I could tailor it to my own requirements.  G4YNM's design has five outputs.  However, four of the outputs are low power and are really intended for input to fixed volume equipment.  I wanted something for up to four users who would need varying amounts of gain based on the individual headphones in use and each individual's listening habits.  Having a bit more power would also be good if someone actually wanted to drive a small speaker. The LM386N-4 audio amplifier chip, which I ultimately chose for this project, has the advantage of being able to supply up to 1 Watt of output, and is designed to withstand up to 22 Volts on its supply.

Above is the schematic supplied with the National Semiconductor data sheet for the LM386.  It is pretty much self explanatory except for the 10 ohm resistor and .05 uF capacitor.  These are for impedance matching of the output.  The only other parts needed for the basic circuit are a potentiometer for the volume adjustment and an output filtering capacitor.  In this format the LN386 is set for a gain of 20.  Optionally adding a bypass network to pins 1 and 8 can increase the gain to 200.

I obtained the needed parts and started fabricating the circuit on a Radio Shack prototype board 276-168.  This 3" by 4" board has been a favorite of mine in the past for various other small projects.  However, when I completed the project, I discovered a few shortcomings.  First, it was difficult servicing the solder side of the board.  The four potentiometers and headphone jacks were mounted to the project box and wired to the board, and this made it difficult to remove the board from the project box.  Bending all the leads to these parts to access the bottom of the board was also difficult.  After a long period of debugging I ended up with only one of the four amplifier circuits working.  I finally had to admit that my eyes are just not as good as they used to be.  I needed another way of producing this project that was easier on my eyes.

What immediately came to mind was the work of the master radio designer Wayne Burdick, N6KR.  Since his famous Norcal 40 QRP transceiver design all the way to the current Elecraft creations, he (and his Elecraft partner Eric Swartz, WA6HHQ) have incorporated "wire-less" construction into all of these kit designs.   To incorporate this feature would entail soldering the potentiometers and jacks directly to the circuit board, and this would require special ordering of the parts.  Also I needed a circuit board with solder lands that were spaced far enough apart and were easier to see to avoid solder bridges that are now more common with my poorer eyesight.  I had a feeling that this new requirement was going to complicate the project.

The schematic that I ended up with is shown above.  There is nothing special about it, except for the 10 uF capacitors shown connected to pin 7 of the LM386.  More on that later.  It is the basic LM386 circuit with additional RF bypassing capacitors added.
Above, on the left is the prototype board layout, and on the right is a slightly more refined final layout.  Both are viewed from the top of the board.  Two files containing the final layout are available here,
BOB 1200 dpi.tif   (2.2 MBs)                  BOB 2400 dpi.tif  (8.7 MBs)

I used TIF format since JPGs do not support a 1 bit black and white format.  Please let me know if you have trouble downloading these files.

I drew up the prototype PCB layout in AutoCAD LT, trying to spread out the traces and make a layout that would be easier for me to solder.  I had to make all the traces from scratch since I did not have any templates for the parts.  So the results may look a bit unconventional, but I feel that the layout makes soldering easier for me.   For the original prototyping board I laid out one complete amplifier circuit first, and then copied this three more times.  I then joined many of the common traces such as for the ground, and the voltage supply.  Finally I added the capability to add more parts to the supply, audio in, and audio out circuits.  This would allow for the addition of RF bypassing capacitors later as I researched that subject.   I felt that I had a nice layout.  The next question was whether I could convert the layout to a high quality circuit board.

And that was a challenge for me.  I had made a small circuit board once using the "iron on a laser print to a clean bare copper board" method, but the quality of the board was disappointing 1.  I started studying different methods of PCB fabrication.  All were much more involved than what I was used to.  I finally decided to try to make a board using the positive resist method.  This method involves using a copper clad board that has been coated with a positive photo sensitive resist.  When the exposed board is developed, areas of the resist coating that have been exposed to light dissolve.  This leaves an image of the circuits on the board.  The board is them etched in a ferric chloride solution to remove the exposed copper.  The result is a circuit board.

I purchased some laser printer transparency film2 to make the positive image for the exposure.  The results were disappointing.  The black image did not appear to be dense enough to be effective.  I finally resolved this by setting up the printing of the image to be only in one quadrant of the transparency.  Since the size for the circuit board is 3 by 4 inches, this allowed four images to be printed on the transparency.  Immediately after running the transparency through the printer for the first image I put it through the printer one more time.  I then rotated the hot (from the fuser) transparency 180 degrees, placed it back into the manual printer tray and printed another image (twice) onto the transparency.  For the third image I flipped the transparency over to its other side, and printed the image again twice.  For the forth image I rotated the transparency again 180 degrees and printed the last image twice.

The results of this effort were interesting.  The first double image was blurred (out of register), while the last three double images were in perfect register.  The double images also had dark enough traces to act as a good positive image for the exposure.  Fortunately the transparency material was two sided, which allowed me to flip the transparency over and print a total of four final images.  I feel the first image was blurred because the transparency was cold for the first printing.  After the transparency was warmed up the second pass for the first image was blurred because the transparency material probably changed dimensions because of the heat from the printer's fuser.  However, the subsequent printings were all done warm and that's why they were in good register.  So I now had a good image of the circuit for the next step.  (In retrospect one pass may be dense enough since the final production of the board revealed great latitude of the system (see below), but I did not test using a single pass transparency to make a PCB.)

For a contact printing frame I borrowed two panes of glass from 5x7 picture frames that were being used to display our family photos.  I placed a Datak 3 by 4 inch Premier board (14-304) over the bottom sheet of glass, then the emulsion side of the positive image over that, and finally a sheet of glass over all of this.  I used small metal binder clips3 to keep the sandwich tightly joined.  I had chosen to use the Datak Premier boards because Datak claims that they could be properly exposed using a standard 100 Watt tungsten bulb at a distance of twelve inches for 10 minutes.  This seemed a lot easier than building an ultraviolet exposure frame.  After exposing the board as recommended I placed the board in a tray of Datak (12-404) developer.  Nothing happened.  I wasn't sure what went wrong but I tried fogging the board by placing the bulb one inch from the developer tray with the board still in the solution.  Again nothing happened.  The bulb was acting more as a safelight, than as an exposure device!

I then read the instructions that were contained on and inside the packaging for the individual boards.  (Datak says to ignore these instructions.)  Since the emulsion is light sensitive it is sealed in a light proof bag.  The outside of the bag had some interesting information on it.  First, I found that the manufacturer was "Kinsten".  Also, they recommended an 8 minute exposure with a 10 to 15 Watt standard fluorescent bulb.  I tended to believe this information more than the Datak information since it was included in the original packaging.  The next night, I took a light fixture from one of my aquariums and placed it on my dining room table.  It has one 95 Watt dual tube compact fluorescent bulb that is so bright when lit that you can't look directly at it.  I shimmed it up so the bulb was about 3 inches from the top of the table.  I then made a test exposure using a new board with the positive image.  By using an opaque piece of cardboard, I was able to make a test strip on the board using exposures of 32, 16, 8, 4, 2, and 1 minute.  I then developed the board as before.  The 32 minute strip developed almost instantaneously.  It took about 20 minutes for the 1 minute strip to fully develop.  After the board was washed I inspected all the strips, and they were perfect except that the 32 minute exposure had a little bit of print through of the traces, but it was still quite usable.  This is amazing to me, as it appears that this system has a great deal of latitude in choosing an exposure.  I decided to use 4 minutes as my standard exposure and exposed another board.  I then put both boards in a warm solution of ferric chloride.  After about 30 minutes I had two very nice printed circuit boards.  Later, I used some brake fluid to remove the resist from the copper traces.

It was now time to build the circuits with the parts that I had collected.  This time the building went quickly as there was no need for installing interconnecting wiring.  The following diagrams explain the layout of the board and where the parts are placed.

This first layout (above) is of the power (red) and ground (gray) systems.  The power cabling (V+, and V-) is connected with two wire loops each soldered to two holes.  Place the power cord wires beneath the loops and solder them into place.  Continuity to the power traces is made via resistor R1, a diode (D1) and jumper (J1).  The power trace is connected to pin 6 of each of the four LM386s.  D1 is used to protect against reverse polarity.  The ground traces require jumpers (J2) through (J5) in order to have continuity.  Pins 2 and 4 of the LM386s are connected to ground.   Although the prototype had both the potentiometers and audio output jacks on the top of the board, I have placed the jacks on the bottom of the board for this final layout to place the jacks farther away from the pots.  This may allow small knobs to be placed on the pots.  To do this the jacks are glued to the trace (bottom) side of the board with five minute epoxy.  Holes are drilled through the board so the one ground lug and both audio connection lugs protrude through the board and are accessible via the top of the board.  Jumpers J6 through J9 connect the jack ground pins to the ground bus.  C1 is a 220 uF electrolytic capacitor.  C2, C3 and C28 are .001, .01, and .1 uF RF bypass capacitors.  Since Field Day can be a very harsh environment for RF interference, you will see that plenty of bypassing has been included in this design.

The above layout is for the audio input.  The "audio in" is applied at the "A+" and "A-" points on the board. Jumpers J10 through J16 route the audio signal to one side of each of the four 5 K Ohm potentiometers, which are placed on the top of the board and soldered in place at the bottom of the board.  The other side of the potentiometers is connected directly to ground.  The center yellow traces connect the wiper of the potentiometers to pin 3 of the LM386s.  C5 through C12 are .01 and .001 uF capacitors to ground on this circuit close to the LM386s for RF bypass.

This layout is for the audio output.  Capacitors C13 through C20 are .01 and 001 uF capacitors to ground for RF bypass and are located close to the audio output of the LM386s (pin 5).  Jumpers J17 through J28 provide continuity of the circuit.  C25 through C28 are 220 uF electrolytic capacitors that are used for coupling to the headphones.  Ten ohm resistors R2 through R5 are in series with .05 uF capacitors C21 through C24, and are part of the impedance matching specified on the LM386 data sheet.
The four amplifier circuits worked perfectly the first time after installing all the parts.  Or so I thought.  Eventually I discovered an anomaly in its operation that almost defeated me.  When I listened to one set of headphones with one amplifier and I plugged in another set of phones and turned up the volume for the second set of phones, I heard  a prominent rushing sound in the headphones.  Sort of like a loud whoosh.  It was evident on all the amplifiers, but only when the second set of phones were plugged in.  When the volume was turned up for another amplifier but no headphone was plugged into the corresponding jack the whoosh did not appear.  I played with different resistances at the input but the noise remained.  I decided to isolate the potentiometers from each other with four unity gain inverted OP amps.  However, this did not help in the least.  I was then guessing that the problem was in the output of the amplifiers.  So I started at look at ways of bypassing the pins of the amplifier.  The datasheet mentioned bypassing pin 7 with a .1 uF capacitor, but only for high amplifications, which was not the case in this design.  I tried this but it did not help.  On a whim I touched a 10 uF electrolytic capacitor to pin 7 and ground and the noise totally disappeared.  The increase in audio quality was startling.  So I tested this mod on all the amplifiers and it appeared to be very reliable.  Later I tried a 1 uF capacitor at this location and it worked well also.  Pin 7 is connected to pin 6 (V+) internally within the LM386 chip with a 15 K Ohm resistor.  Because of this I also tried bypassing pin 6 with a 10 uF capacitor but this did not help.  So adding four 10 uF capacitors to the number 7 pins finalized the project.

The effort to make the circuit board from scratch was justified.  It took considerable time to debug the PCB process, but after this, it was actually very easy to quickly make the boards, and subsequently to install the parts.  I will definitely not hesitate to make other boards of designs in the future if the need arises.   Not only does BOB work well and sound good, but it also looks much better than using a proto board.  On my transceiver I normally run the audio volume at about 9 o'clock.  This gives plenty of volume and then each user can adjust their potentiometer on BOB for their own preference.

Installing the parts took far less time than the original attempt on a prototype board as no interconnecting wiring was needed.  The installation of the jumpers could also be avoided resulting in less construction time if the board was made double sided.  This I only recommend for a production version of the board.  For small quantities I prefer a single sided board.

The final version of the board simplified the layout and eliminated some jumpers, but the circuit design remained unchanged.  I now have a reliable way to demonstrate "hands on" amateur radio to potential hams.

 
 
 
This is the transparency sheet after feeding it eight times through the laser printer. (Note that most of these photos are of the prototype board.) This is the double copied image ready to be used to make a circuit board.
Here is the exposure setup using a 100 Watt tungsten bulb.  This did not work. Here you can see the transparency over the bluish colored photo sensitive resist material.
This is the setup for using a fluorescent bulb for exposure.  The light fixture was borrowed from one of my aquariums. This was taken during the exposure test.  Visible are the 32, 16, and 8 minute test strips.  Note that the 8 minute strip has a greenish tint to it.
This is an exposed board that has been developed.  The green image of the traces has been left on the copper. This is the board after it was etched in ferric chloride.  The exposed copper was removed from the board.
This is the board after I wiped the green resist off of the copper traces using brake fluid, and drilled the holes with a #66 carbide drill bit. Note the personalized lettering.  You might as well flaunt your craftsmanship. Note the good quality of the traces.
This is the completed board.  Note that the potentiometers and jacks are close together.  Getting eight items in a space of four inches is a challenge.  This is the proto board.  The final design places the jacks on the bottom of the board. This is a view of the board from the rear side.
This is a view of the power section.  Note how the supply wires are soldered under loops of wire, and then nylon ties are used to keep the wires secure to the board. Here is a view of the potentiometers and jacks.  The jacks on the prototype where a bit loose and five minute epoxy putty was eventually used to attach the jacks to the sides of the potentiometer cases for added rigidity.
My first BOB was complete about one week before 2007 Field Day.  I had wanted to make two other copies of it so each station could have one for people to try out, but my schedule did not permit this and I came to Field Day with just one BOB.  I was a bit skeptical about its use being accepted, but I hooked it up to my transceiver which was going to be used for the CW station.  Usually the CW station is the ugly duckling of the group.  In past Field Days we have had only one or two dedicated CW enthusiasts to man the station and it often went unused when they needed to rest.  This year the other dedicated CW operator in our club could not attend, and I was mentally preparing myself for a solo attempt.  However, this time we not only kept the station occupied the entire 24 hours of the event but had three people listening most of the time, and for one stretch had four listening, when a fourth set of phones became available.   The increase in activity at the CW station seemed to be associated with BOB.  From the photos you can see that people were laughing much of the time.  It is a lot easier to agree with (and laugh about) what is going on "on frequency" when all can hear exactly what the other people are hearing.  Loggers also get more involved and have less chance of becoming bored when they hear exactly what the operator is hearing.  Several seasoned CW operators came out of the woodwork and listened in for much of the time, offering corrections for some of what the less experienced operators were transcribing.  Some of these hams had never let on that they even knew CW.  In all, thanks to BOB, we had a blast.  It seems that people were always a bit apprehensive about manning the CW station, but when they see two unused sets of headphones, it tends to reinforce the welcome we gave them urging them to participate.  We ended up converting the GOTA station to CW use because of the congestion at the regular CW station.

During Field Day we had a visit from a Boy Scout leader from Houston who was very impressed with BOB.  He felt that two BOBs in parallel (8 listeners) would be about perfect for radio merit badge work.

In this photo one can see the epoxy putty applied to stabilize the jacks.  We used a 2.3 AH gel cell to power BOB for the entire contest.  During solo work the operators did not disconnect BOB and plug their phones straight into the transceiver.  It seems that they preferred the extra punch that BOB gave to the audio. Here BOB is shown in a position between the operator and the logger.  Normally the operator and logger will take the end jacks to have good access to their respective volume controls, and the two observers can use the two center jacks.
Three casual CW operators having a blast comparing their listening skills (and debating what was really sent).  (l to r: AK5U, W0IT, and W5ASD Here we are at the peak with four listeners.  (l to r: W5ASD, WD5GYG, wife of W5ASD, and KE5CVM.
Footnotes:

1   http://www.pituch.net/p/Steve's%20Page/Radio/SW40+/SW40+.html
2   Office Depot small binder clips (3/4") (429-415)film
3   Office Depot Black & White Laser Transparencies (753-611)

 

Parts List
Quan PCB Designation Vendor Vendor Part Number Description    
4   Digikey P3U0502-ND 5 K Potentiometer 1.56 6.24
    Digikey CP1-3523NG-ND 3.5 mm Jack .333 1.33
9 C3, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18, 20 Digikey P4551-ND .001 uF Capacitor .072 2.48
9 C2, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19 Digikey P4582-ND .01 uF Capacitor .072 2.48
1 C2 Digikey P4593-ND .1 uF Capacitor .129 .129
5 C1, C25 through C28 Digikey P12412-ND 220 uF Electrolytic Cap .27 1.35
4 C21 through C24 Digikey P4589-ND .047 uF Capacitor .093 .37
4   Digikey LM386N-4-ND LM384N-4 .94 3.76
5   Digikey 10QBK-ND 10 Ohm 1/4 Watt resistor .054 .27
4   Electronic Goldmine   8 pin IC Socket .08 .32
1   Jameco 156751 4x5 single sided sensitized circuit board 5.19 5.19
1   Jameco 156734 Datak 12-404 positive developer 6.95 6.95
1   Jameco 70201 Datak ER-3 etchant 4.55 4.55
  TOTAL 35.42

Go Back to Steve's Radio Page

Go Back to the Pituch Family Page